Email Marketing Analytics: How to Measure and Report on the Most Important Metrics

Email Marketing Analytics: How to Measure and Report on the Most Important Metrics Measuring email marketing and extracting actionable insights from your performance data doesn’t have to feel like rocket science. Once you know what to measure, how to set goals, and report progress, you can easily build a repeatable analytics process to refine your strategy. In this guide, you’ll learn:
  • How to choose which email metrics matter most for your business.
  • How to calculate and measure those data points (and understand what they mean).
  • How to develop a simple email marketing analysis and reporting process.
Now, let’s turn you into an analytics maestro.

Email Marketing Analytics: How to Measure and Report on the Most Important Metrics via @CoSchedule

Click To Tweet

What Are the Most Important Email Marketing Metrics Every Business Should Monitor?

Every organization has different needs. However, there are some basic data points most businesses should be tracking to gauge success. Here’s a complete breakdown. How to Calculate Eight Important Email Marketing Metrics

Understanding Open Rate

Your open rate is the percentage of emails opened relative to the total number of recipients. It’s important to note this is based on actual emails delivered, excluding addresses that were sent to but didn’t actually get the message. How to Calculate Open Rate Email service providers consider an email “opened” when a tracking pixel (a small transparent image) is shown to the reader. This triggers an “open,” but it can be misleading if recipients have images blocked in their email client. So, this is something to keep in mind.

How to Improve Open Rates

The best way to improve your open rate is to write compelling subject lines. It’s also worth paying attention to your pre-header text (the text that appears immediately after the subject line in some email clients): Example of Pre-Header Text Add text + arrows pointing out the Subject Line, and the Pre-header Text. You can optimize subject lines before sending using the free Email Subject Line Tester. Visit the site and enter a subject line: ESLT Screenshot Get your score: Add words shown to increase open rates (and remove ones shown to decrease them): And get tips on how to structure your subject line for best performance: Start testing your own subject lines.

Understanding Click-Through Rates

Click-through rate (CTR) measures how many people click links in your emails. The more people click, the better. CTR is calculated based on the percentage of unique users who click a link, relative to the total number of recipients on your list. How to Calculate Click Through Rate

How to Improve Click-Through Rates

Strong CTRs start with strong subject lines. Your email content needs to follow through on the promises your subject line makes. Next, work on your email copywriting skills. That content has to be compelling and written in a way that makes people want to check out what you’re offering, whether that’s a blog post, a sales offer, or something else.

Understanding Click-to-Open Rates

Click-to-Open Rate (CTOR) is similar to CTR, except it’s calculated by the number of people who clicked, relative to the number of people who opened the email. How to Calculate Click to Open Rate

Understanding Conversion Rate

Your conversion rate calculates the number of goal completions driven by your email. This usually means things like:
  • Sign-up form completions.
  • Direct purchases.
  • Downloads.
Whatever constitutes a conversion on your blog, website, or landing page, referred from a marketing email. Conversion rate is calculated the same way as open rate and CTR. Divide the number of email opens by the number of clicks, and multiply it by 100. How to Calculate Conversion Rate

How to Improve Email Conversion Rates

The subject line gets the recipient’s attention. Then, the email copy convinces them to click. Now, your webpage copy (whether it’s a blog post, web page, or landing page) needs to seal the deal. If your emails are getting opens and clicks, but conversions are landing, there could be a few things worth looking at:
  • The copy may not match the same promises made in the email. Try working on your message-match.
  • That copy might also just not be well-written. No shortcuts here. The copy needs to be better written.
  • The page may be poorly structured, making it difficult to complete a conversion. Confusing ecommerce site pages or poorly formatted forms are common culprits here.
In order to track conversion rates, your site or blog will need to be connected to Google Analytics or another web analytics platform.

Understanding Bounce Rate

Bounce rate equal the number of emails that couldn’t be delivered. They’re categorized into two groups:
  • Soft Bounces: Emails that couldn’t be sent because an inbox was full, or some sort of technical error.
  • Hard Bounces: Emails sent to addresses that no longer exist.
Again, this can be calculated using the same formula as other metrics. Divide the number of bounces against the number of email addresses delivered to, and multiply that by 100. How to Calculate Bounce Rate

How to Improve Your Bounce Rate

In the case of hard bounces, prune those email addresses from your list. Done. The folks at SendGrid also offer some more great tips:
  1. Use double opt-in forms. This entails having email subscribers click a confirmation email link after signing up. The benefit is it weeds out fake emails.
  2. Monitor your bounce rate in your ESP. If it’s high, you’ve got problems that need attention.
  3. Be mindful of soft bounces, but don’t remove those email addresses yet. Focus on fixing hard bounces.

Understanding List Growth Rate

Before your email marketing can succeed, you need subscribers! It seems obvious, but building a strong list is easier said than done. List growth rate is a calculation of how many subscribers you’re adding. Generally, you can measure this month-to-month. How to Calculate List Growth Rate

How to Improve List Growth

List building is a massive topic unto itself. At a basic level, here are some useful strategies CoSchedule has used to build a list of 300,000+ subscribers:
  • Put a lot of effort into creating content upgrades. These are downloadable resources gated behind an email opt-in form. They typically include templates, eBooks, PDFs, and other similar assets.
  • Add an email subscription form to your blog home page. Provide some freebies for signing up there, too.
  • Host events. These can be things like webinars (which are popular with the CoSchedule audience), or real-world events requiring email submissions to register (which may be better for businesses with a physical presence).

Understanding Unsubscribe Rate

People are going to unsubscribe from your list. It’s a fact of life, and it’s best to come to terms with it. But, if your unsubscribes are high, you may have some problems. You certainly want to do everything you can to encourage people to stay on your list, too. Your unsubscribe rate is a measurement of how many people leaving your list. Calculate it by taking the number of users unsubscribing and comparing it against your total number of subscribers. How to Calculate Unsubscribe Rate

How to Improve Your Unsubscribe Rate

The answer starts with understanding why people might choose to unsubscribe in the first place:
  • Getting too many emails. Try reducing send frequency.
  • Not getting value from email. Create better content. No shortcuts.
  • They didn’t mean to subscribe. Double opt-in signups can help with this.

Understanding Email ROI

This is the big one. Email marketing is extremely cost-effective. Various studies pin its ROI somewhere between 3,800% and 4,200% (give or take). That’s absolutely incredible value. If you have Google Analytics or another analytics platform set up, email ROI can be calculated easily. Find the number of conversions on your site that were referred by email, then figure out how much revenue those conversions were worth. There are a couple ways to do this:
  • For ecommerce companies, ROI should be easy to measure. People make purchases directly on your site, and you can see that directly in Google Analytics.
  • For other businesses, knowing exactly how much each conversion is worth might be more difficult, if it can’t be tracked directly in your analytics platform.
However, you can still calculate the average value of a conversion for your site, times the total number of conversions. This will give you an approximate understanding of your email ROI. To find conversion data from email in Google Analytics, follow this path: Acquisition: Google Analytics: Acquisition All Traffic Channels: GA: Channels Email: Google Analytics: Channels Conversions (scroll to the right): Where to find Conversions in Google Analytics This will help you find:
  • Conversion Rate: The rate at which email referral traffic is converting.
  • Total Goal Completions: The gross number of conversions.
  • Goal Value: The monetary value of those conversions.
Now, for non-ecommerce sites, the Goal Value might not be accurate, or may display as $0.00. In this case, you can get close by following these steps:
  1. Find your total number of conversions. That’s your total goal completions.
  2. Learn the average value of a single conversion. This might mean looking outside Google Analytics or your email service provider. If you’re unsure how to find this information in your particular circumstance, try talking to someone on the accounting side of the business to learn your average order or purchase value.
  3. Multiply your conversions from email by the average value of a conversion. This won’t be exact, but it’s better than a total guess.
At the very least, this will help provide a starting point to understanding how email marketing is impacting your bottom line.

Measuring Your Own Email Marketing Performance

Most email service providers include robust analytics features. They also integrate with Google Analytics (and in some cases, several other popular analytics tools). These links will get you started in the right direction, if you use any of the email services that currently integrate with CoSchedule:

Developing an Email Marketing Analytics Process

We’ve established there are plenty of tools for gathering and tracking email marketing data. But, how do you understand which elements of your emails drove specific results and behaviors? This can be challenging to narrow down, and requires testing and a little bit of subjective interpretation.

Step 1: Check Subject Line A/B Test

It’s always worth split testing subject lines. But, you have to make sure you’re actually reviewing the results, and acting on that data the next time you write an email. This video offers a great primer on subject line A/B testing:

Using the report template included in this post, record your results for the past month (this data should be easy to find in your email service provider): Slide to track email subject line A/B test results When evaluating subject lines, consider the following:
  • What promise did each one make?
  • Did one include a number, stat, or emoji?
  • Are there differences in tone or emotional sentiment?
Keep those thoughts in mind as you write and test subject lines for your next send.

Step 2: Review Your Email Copy, Images, and Design

Next, it’s time to be your own worst critic. Honestly assess all elements of your email.
  • Copy: Analyze messaging, tone, and calls to action.
  • Images: Note color choices, products included, and other elements.
  • Design: Review scannability, whether it looks good on mobile devices, and anything else about your design that could impact user experience.
Using your template, screenshot each email and provide your analytical insights for each send: Email marketing strategy slide: Insights

Step 3: Choose One Element to Adjust in Your Next Email

This could mean:
  • Striking a different tone in your email.
  • Offering a different type of benefit.
  • Changing the color of your CTA buttons.
  • Featuring different products.
  • Sharing different types of content on different topics.
What matters most is being intentional about the changes you’re making. Inform your team or client which elements you’ll adjust on upcoming emails:

Email Analytics Report Slide: Next Steps

Step 4: Compare Differences in Results

Then, send your email, and watch what happens. Keep repeating this process to refine your execution and continue to improve your results. Over time, you’ll see trends develop that will provide you with better understanding of which actions influence changes on different metrics.

Email Marketing Industry Benchmarks

When measuring email marketing performance, it’s helpful to compare your data against industry averages. These can vary widely between different industries and niches, which is important to keep in mind. By Industry: Complete list of email marketing benchmarks By Company Size: Average Email Campaign Stats By Company Size Use these numbers as loose guideposts to understand if your performance is exceptional, on par, or needs improvement.

Manage Email Marketing With CoSchedule

CoSchedule is a powerful all-in-one marketing management platform for organizing teams, projects, and campaigns. But, here’s something you might not know: that includes email marketing. CoSchedule integrates with the following ESPs, giving your entire team full visibility into your email marketing strategy:
  • MailChimp
  • Campaign Monitor
  • Active Campaign
  • Constant Contact
Once you connect your ESP to CoSchedule in a few simple steps, all email content you create will appear on your calendar: This helps:
  • Your entire team see every email send. Email often complements broader marketing campaigns. Planning and collaboration are much easier when everyone can visualize one version of truth.
  • Make sure every email is delivered at the best time. Rather than winging it and sending email when you get around to it, you can proactively plan every send at the optimal day and time.
Best of all, you can schedule a demo to see how it works.

How to Improve Email Marketing Performance

Once you start measuring email marketing, you’ll naturally want to see your numbers continue to improve. The only way to do this is to develop your skill set as an email marketer. Fortunately, there are tons of resources to help, including these from CoSchedule:

Master Email Marketing Analytics

Wrangling metrics and meeting your goals doesn’t have to feel like a trip to the dentist. In fact, equipped with this post, you’re now fully prepared to leverage analytics to show your boss value. Here’s a recap of what you’ve learned:
  • Which email metrics actually matter (and how should they be measured)?
  • What do you do with email marketing data (and turn it into actionable insight)?
  • How can marketers explain email performance bosses and clients?
Plus, you’ve got all the templates you need to get organized and create easy reports. Is there anything we missed? Drop a comment below and start the discussion. Ready to try managing email marketing with CoSchedule? Get started free or schedule a personalized demo now.
About the Author

Ben Sailer has over 14 years of experience in the field of marketing. He is considered an expert in inbound marketing through his incredible skills with copywriting, SEO, content strategy, and project management. Ben is currently an Inbound Marketing Director at Automattic, working to grow as the top managed hosting solution for WordPress websites. WordPress is one of the most powerful website creation tools in the industry. In this role, he looks to attract customers with content designed to attract qualified leads. Ben plays a critical role in driving the growth and success of a company by attracting and engaging customers through relevant and helpful content and interactions. Ben works closely with senior management to align the inbound marketing efforts with the overall business objectives. He continuously measures the effectiveness of marketing campaigns to improve them. He is also involved in managing budgets and mentoring the inbound marketing team.